Venn diagrams and two-way tables for two attributes: filling in the regions, converting between the two displays, and finding probabilities and proportions (new in the 2024 Mathematics Standard syllabus)
“Construct and interpret Venn diagrams and two-way tables from given information, limited to combinations of two attributes, and use them to solve problems in a variety of contexts”
For two attributes, a Venn diagram has four regions (A only, both, B only, neither) and a two-way table has the same four cells. Fill "both" first, subtract it from each total, then find neither from the grand total. Probabilities are region counts over the total, except "of those who ..." questions, which divide by that group. Part of Year 12 Relative frequency and probability in the 2024 Mathematics Standard syllabus.
What this dot point is asking
In the Mathematics Standard 11-12 Syllabus (2024), first examined in the 2027 HSC, relative frequency and probability moved from Year 11 to Year 12, and it now includes this content point: "construct and interpret Venn diagrams and two-way tables from given information, limited to combinations of two attributes, and use them to solve problems in a variety of contexts". Two-way tables appeared in the 2017 course (for example in expected-frequency problems), but Venn diagrams are new to Mathematics Standard.
"Two attributes" means every question involves exactly two yes/no characteristics (plays sport or not, owns a dog or not), so every diagram has two circles and every table has two rows and two columns of data.
Think of a class photo where everyone who plays sport stands in one hoop on the floor and everyone who plays music stands in another. The hoops overlap, and the people who do both stand in the overlap. Anyone who does neither stands outside both hoops. Counting the people in each part of the floor tells you everything: how many do sport, how many do music, how many do both and how many do neither. A two-way table is the same count written in a grid.
The answer
A Venn diagram for two attributes and has four regions: only, both, only, and neither. Fill the overlap first, then subtract it from each circle total:
Probabilities are counts over the relevant total. For "of those who have ", divide by , not by the whole total.
Filling in a Venn diagram
Take a class of students where play sport, play music and do both.
- Both: .
- Sport only: . Music only: .
- At least one: . Neither: .
Now read off anything the question asks: , , , and of the music students, also play sport.
The same information as a two-way table
| Music | No music | Total | |
|---|---|---|---|
| Sport | |||
| No sport | |||
| Total |
Each inner cell is one Venn region: "sport and music" is the overlap, "sport, no music" is sport only, "no sport, music" is music only, and "no sport, no music" is neither. Rows and columns must add to their totals, which is a built-in check.
Choosing the right denominator
Most lost marks come from dividing by the wrong total:
- "What is the probability that a student plays music?" uses the whole group: .
- "Of the students who play music, what proportion play sport?" uses only the music students: .
The second kind of question is how statistics are used (and misused) in the media, which the syllabus also asks you to examine.
How exam questions ask about it
- "Complete the Venn diagram / two-way table." Start from "both", then the "only" regions, then neither.
- "How many have neither?" or "how many have both?" Use and the total.
- "Find the probability that ..." Count the region(s) and divide by the total, unless the question restricts the group.
- "Of those who ..., what proportion ...?" Divide by that group's total.
- "Estimate the number in a population." Multiply the relative frequency by the population size (expected frequency ).
Find a missing overlap
In a class of , study Legal Studies, study Business Studies and study neither. At least one: . The circle totals add to , which counts the overlap twice, so both . Then Legal only , Business only .
Marker's note: showing "" with a reason (double counting) earns the method mark.
Build a two-way table and read a proportion
vaccinated adults include who caught the flu; unvaccinated adults include who caught it. The table has rows vaccinated / not vaccinated and columns flu / no flu: and , with column totals and . Of the who caught the flu, were vaccinated, but the rates within each group are and .
Marker's note: when comparing two groups of different sizes, compare rates within each group, not raw counts.
From percentages
If exercise, smoke and do both, then exercise only , smoke only , neither . For adults that is adults in neither.
Marker's note: percentages fill a Venn diagram exactly like counts; convert to numbers at the end.
- Putting the circle total in the "only" region
- If play sport and do both, "sport only" is , not .
- Adding circle totals to get "at least one"
- double counts the in both; the correct count is .
- Forgetting the "neither" region
- It must be included for the diagram to add to the total.
- Wrong denominator
- "Of those who ..." restricts the group; divide by that group's size.
- Reading "or" as "only one"
- In probability " or " includes both.
Draw the diagram or table even if the question does not ask for it, and write the overlap first. Check that the four regions add to the total before answering. Circle the words "of those who" in a question: they tell you to change the denominator. Give probabilities as simplified fractions or decimals, and multiply by the population size for "estimate how many" questions.
Exam-style questions
Questions in the style of NESA exam questions on this dot point, each with a worked answer. They are written by ExamExplained unless tagged "Past paper"; the year shows the paper a question is modelled on.
HSC-style3 marksIn a group of students, study Biology, study Chemistry and study both. (a) How many students study neither subject? (b) A student is chosen at random. Find the probability that they study exactly one of the two subjects.Show worked answer →
Biology only and Chemistry only , so study at least one.
(a) Neither .
(b) Exactly one , so .
Markers look for the overlap subtracted from each circle total, a correct count of neither, and the probability using the whole group of as the denominator.
HSC-style3 marksA survey of phone users recorded the type of phone and whether the user was under . Of the Android users, were under . Of the iPhone users, were under . (a) Find the probability that a randomly chosen user is under . (b) Of the users under , what proportion use an iPhone?Show worked answer →
Under : .
(a) .
(b) Restrict to the users under : .
Markers expect a two-way table (or equivalent working) and, in (b), the denominator , not .
Practice questions
Original practice questions graded from foundation to exam level, each with a full worked solution. Try them before revealing the solution.
foundation2 marksA Venn diagram for two attributes and shows in " only", in "both", in " only" and outside both circles. Find the total number of people and the probability that a randomly chosen person has attribute .Show worked solution →
Total. Add all four regions: .
Has . The circle is " only" plus "both": , so
Marker's note: one mark for , one for . Using alone (forgetting the overlap) is the usual error.
foundation2 marksOf people, like tea, like coffee and like both. Complete a Venn diagram and state how many like neither.Show worked solution →
Start with the overlap. Both: . Tea only: . Coffee only: .
Neither. .
Marker's note: one mark for the three inner regions, one for .
core3 marksIn a survey of drivers, had received a speeding fine, a parking fine and both. Show this information in a two-way table, and find the probability that a randomly chosen driver had received neither kind of fine.Show worked solution →
Fill the table from the overlap.
| Parking fine | No parking fine | Total | |
|---|---|---|---|
| Speeding fine | |||
| No speeding fine | |||
| Total |
(Speeding only ; parking only ; neither .)
Probability. .
Marker's note: one mark for the "both" cell and the two "only" cells, one for a consistent table with totals, one for .
core3 marksIn a class of students, study Legal Studies, study Business Studies and study neither. How many study both? Find the probability that a randomly chosen student studies exactly one of the two subjects.Show worked solution →
- At least one
- students study at least one subject.
- Both
- The two circle totals add to , which counts the overlap twice, so both .
- Exactly one
- Legal only and Business only , so students and
Marker's note: one mark for (reasoning about the double count), one for the two "only" regions, one for .
core3 marksA health survey of adults recorded whether each was vaccinated and whether they caught the flu. were vaccinated, and of them caught the flu. Of the unvaccinated adults, caught the flu. (a) Of the adults who caught the flu, what proportion were vaccinated? (b) Compare the rate of catching the flu in the two groups.Show worked solution →
(a) Restrict to the flu row. caught the flu, and of these were vaccinated: .
(b) Compare within each group. Vaccinated: . Unvaccinated: . The unvaccinated group caught the flu at four times the rate.
Marker's note: one mark for (a); two marks for (b), which needs both rates. The trap is to compare with directly, ignoring that the groups are different sizes.
exam4 marksA survey of households in a town found that own a dog, own a cat and own both. (a) Find the probability that a household owns a dog or a cat. (b) The town has households. Estimate how many own neither a dog nor a cat.Show worked solution →
(a) At least one. Dog or cat , so the relative frequency is
(b) Neither in the sample. , a relative frequency of .
Expected number. households.
Marker's note: one mark for , one for , one for , one for (expected frequency ).
exam4 marksA report on adults states: "60% exercise regularly, 30% smoke, and 10% both exercise regularly and smoke." (a) How many of the adults neither exercise regularly nor smoke? (b) A headline says "Most smokers exercise regularly." Use the data to decide whether this is supported.Show worked solution →
(a) Percentages to a Venn diagram. Both: . Exercise only: . Smoke only: . Neither: , which is adults.
(b) Look only at the smokers. Smokers are of the adults, and of the adults are smokers who exercise. So the proportion of smokers who exercise is . Only a third of smokers exercise regularly, so the headline is not supported.
Marker's note: two marks for (a); two for (b), which must restrict attention to the smokers (the ), not all adults.