Why is the total momentum of an isolated system the same before and after a collision, even when kinetic energy is lost?
Apply conservation of momentum to elastic and inelastic collisions in one dimension, and distinguish them using kinetic energy.
How conservation of momentum solves one-dimensional collisions, the difference between elastic and inelastic collisions, and why momentum is conserved while kinetic energy may not be.
Reviewed by: AI editorial process; not yet individually human-reviewed
Have a quick question? Jump to the Q&A page
Jump to a section
What this dot point is asking
You need to apply the law of conservation of momentum to one-dimensional collisions, write a correct before-and-after momentum equation (with signs for direction), and use kinetic energy to decide whether a collision is elastic or inelastic.
Why momentum is conserved
Newton's third law says the forces two colliding bodies exert on each other are equal and opposite. During the collision these are the only significant forces (the collision is brief), so the impulse on one body is the exact negative of the impulse on the other. Equal and opposite impulses mean equal and opposite momentum changes, so the total momentum change of the system is zero.
The "isolated" condition matters. If an external force such as friction or an applied push acts during the interaction, momentum is not conserved for the bodies alone. In most SACE collision problems we treat the interaction as brief enough that external forces are negligible over the contact time.
Elastic vs inelastic collisions
The dividing line is kinetic energy, not momentum (momentum is conserved in both).
To classify a collision, compute the total before and after. If they match, it is elastic; if after is less, it is inelastic. You can never decide elasticity from momentum alone, because momentum is conserved either way.
Solving a collision
- Draw before and after, mark velocities with signs.
- Write the momentum equation and substitute known values.
- If the objects stick together (perfectly inelastic), use one final velocity for both.
- To classify, compare the total kinetic energy before and after.
Most SACE collision questions are one-dimensional, so a single signed equation is enough. The hardest step is sign bookkeeping: a velocity to the left is negative if you chose right as positive, and forgetting this flips the answer.
Recoil and explosions
An "explosion" is the reverse of a perfectly inelastic collision: a system starts at rest (total momentum zero) and separates into pieces. Because total momentum stays zero, the pieces fly apart with equal and opposite momenta. This is how recoil works: a fired projectile and the gun gain momenta of equal magnitude in opposite directions, so a light bullet leaves fast while the heavier gun recoils slowly.
The same algebra handles a person stepping off a stationary boat, or a trolley releasing a spring-loaded block: the total momentum is zero before and after, so .
Exam-style practice questions
Practice questions written in the style of SACE Board exam questions on this dot point, with worked answer explainers. The year tag is the paper they imitate, not the source.
SACE 20234 marksA car moving east at collides head-on with a van moving west at . The two vehicles lock together. (a) Calculate the common velocity immediately after the collision. (b) Show that the collision is inelastic.Show worked answer →
Take east as positive and apply conservation of momentum, .
(a) .
So , giving : the wreck is momentarily stationary. (2 marks)
(b) Compare kinetic energy. Before: .
After: .
All is converted to heat, sound and deformation, so the collision is inelastic. (2 marks) Markers reward the signed momentum sum and the explicit before/after comparison.
SACE 20223 marksA ball moving right at collides elastically with a stationary ball. After the collision the ball rebounds at . Calculate the velocity of the ball and confirm the collision is consistent with being elastic.Show worked answer →
Take right as positive. Conservation of momentum: .
Elastic check: before .
After .
The kinetic energy is conserved to rounding, consistent with an elastic collision. Markers award the signed momentum equation, the value of , and the kinetic-energy comparison.
