Skip to main content

Speciation - TCE Biology (Tasmania)

Syllabus dot point

“Analyse differing selection pressures between geographically isolated populations to demonstrate the process of speciation; represent and analyse the accumulation of micro-evolutionary changes over time and macro-evolutionary changes resulting in speciation”

TCEBiologyEvolution (Module 3)7 min read

Quick answer

Speciation is the formation of new species when populations become reproductively isolated and their gene pools diverge until they can no longer interbreed to produce fertile offspring. Isolation can occur because of a geographic barrier (allopatric) or within the same area (sympatric).

What this dot point is asking

What is a species

Under the biological species concept, a species is a group of organisms that can interbreed in nature to produce fertile, viable offspring. Members of one species share a gene pool, the total of all alleles in the population. Speciation occurs when one gene pool splits into two that no longer mix.

Reproductive isolation

Reproductive isolation is the prevention of gene flow between populations, so that they no longer interbreed successfully. It is the essential step that allows two populations to diverge into separate species.

The general process of speciation

Speciation usually follows a sequence:

  1. A single population shares one gene pool.
  2. The population is split or divided so gene flow between the groups is reduced or stopped.
  3. The separated groups experience different selection pressures, mutations, and genetic drift, so their allele frequencies diverge over many generations.
  4. The groups become so genetically different that, even if reunited, they can no longer interbreed to produce fertile offspring. They are now separate species.

Allopatric speciation

Allopatric speciation happens when a physical (geographic) barrier separates populations. The barrier might be a mountain range, a river, an ocean, or new land formed by geological change. With gene flow blocked, the two populations evolve independently. This is thought to be the most common form of speciation. The Galapagos finches are a classic example: ancestral finches reached different islands, and isolation plus different food sources led to distinct beak shapes and eventually distinct species.

A river divides a population

A population of insects lives across a valley. A river changes course and splits the population into two, with no individuals able to cross. On the wetter side, selection favours one wing form; on the drier side, a different form. Over thousands of generations the two groups accumulate enough genetic differences that, if the river later dries up and they meet again, they no longer mate successfully. Two species have formed by allopatric speciation.

Sympatric speciation

Sympatric speciation happens without geographic separation, while populations still share the same area. Gene flow is interrupted by biological factors instead. Examples of how this can occur include:

  • Polyploidy: a sudden change in chromosome number, common in plants, that immediately prevents successful breeding with the parent population.
  • Behavioural shifts: groups using different food sources or breeding at different times stop interbreeding.

Sympatric speciation is generally rarer than allopatric speciation in animals but is important in plants.

Rates of speciation: gradualism and punctuated equilibrium

Speciation does not always happen at a steady pace. Two models describe how fast it can occur. Gradualism proposes that species change slowly and steadily over very long periods, with new species emerging through the gradual accumulation of small changes. Punctuated equilibrium proposes that species stay much the same for long periods (stasis) and then change rapidly over a relatively short time, often when the environment changes quickly or a small population becomes isolated. The fossil record shows examples that fit both patterns, so they are best seen as two ends of a spectrum rather than rival theories. Recognising that speciation can be slow or rapid helps explain why some transitional fossils are common while others are rare, and why isolated island groups such as the Galapagos finches can diversify comparatively quickly once they reach a new, empty habitat with many vacant niches.

Isolating mechanisms

Once divergence begins, isolating mechanisms keep gene pools separate. They are grouped by whether they act before or after mating.

  • Prezygotic mechanisms prevent mating or fertilisation. These include temporal isolation (breeding at different times), behavioural isolation (different courtship signals), and ecological or habitat isolation (living in different microhabitats).
  • Postzygotic mechanisms act after fertilisation. These include hybrid inviability (offspring do not survive) and hybrid sterility (offspring survive but cannot reproduce, like the mule).
Isolation must reduce gene flow

The common thread in all speciation is the reduction or loss of gene flow between groups. Whatever the cause, geographic or biological, populations cannot diverge into new species while alleles continue to flow freely between them.

Thinking speciation is fast and deliberate

Speciation is usually a gradual process that takes many generations, and it is not directed toward a goal. Populations do not set out to become new species. Divergence happens through accumulated changes in allele frequencies once gene flow is blocked, and only in hindsight do we recognise that two species have formed.

Scope for the TASC exam

The course asks you to analyse how differing selection pressures on geographically isolated populations lead to speciation, and how micro-evolutionary changes (changes in allele frequencies through natural selection, mutation, gene flow and genetic drift) accumulate over time into macro-evolutionary change (new species). The external assessment specifications do not require the terms allopatric and sympatric, so sympatric speciation and rates of speciation are background. Describe the process in terms of isolation, no gene flow, different selection pressures, changing allele frequencies and, eventually, reproductive isolation.

Exam-style questions

Questions in the style of TASC exam questions on this dot point, each with a worked answer. They are written by ExamExplained unless tagged "Past paper"; the year shows the paper a question is modelled on.

Original7 marks
A single population of beetles lives on a plateau. A new river forms and splits the population into two groups that can no longer meet. After many generations the two groups can no longer interbreed even when brought back together. Name and describe the mode of speciation shown, explain each step in order, and state how you would confirm that two new species had formed.
Show worked answer →

A 7 mark answer names allopatric speciation, sequences the steps and gives a species test.

Mode
This is allopatric speciation (speciation by geographic isolation).
Step 1 - geographic isolation
The river physically separates the population into two groups, stopping gene flow between them.
Step 2 - independent change
Each group experiences different selection pressures, mutations and genetic drift, so their gene pools diverge over many generations.
Step 3 - reproductive isolation
The accumulated genetic differences eventually mean the two groups can no longer interbreed to produce fertile offspring, even if reunited.
Confirming two species
Apply the biological species concept: bring the groups together and check whether they can interbreed to produce fertile, viable offspring. If they cannot, they are reproductively isolated and are separate species.

Markers reward naming allopatric speciation, the isolation/divergence/reproductive-isolation sequence, and the fertile-offspring test for separate species.

Original5 marks
Distinguish between prezygotic and postzygotic isolating mechanisms, giving one example of each, and explain why a sterile mule supports the biological species concept.
Show worked answer →

A 5 mark answer contrasts the two mechanism types with examples and applies them to the mule.

Prezygotic isolation
Mechanisms that prevent mating or fertilisation, so no zygote forms. Example: temporal isolation (breeding at different times) or behavioural isolation (different mating calls).
Postzygotic isolation
Mechanisms acting after a zygote forms, reducing the fitness of hybrids. Example: hybrid sterility or hybrid inviability.
The mule
A horse and a donkey can mate and produce a mule (a zygote forms), but the mule is sterile, so it cannot reproduce. This is postzygotic isolation. Because the two parent species cannot produce fertile offspring, they remain separate species under the biological species concept.

Markers reward the before/after fertilisation distinction with valid examples and the explanation that hybrid sterility keeps horse and donkey as separate species.

Practise this

Sources & how we know this

ExamExplained