Back to the full dot-point answer
NSWEnglishQuick questions
Module C: The Craft of Writing
Quick questions on The reflection statement in HSC English Advanced Module C
15short Q&A pairs drawn directly from our worked dot-point answer. For full context and worked exam questions, read the parent dot-point page.
What is what a reflection statement is for?Show answer
The reflection has three functions in Module C.
What is what a reflection statement is not?Show answer
Three patterns that read as the wrong form.
What is the shape of a working reflection?Show answer
A reflection is short. A 5-mark reflection is around 200 to 300 words; a 10-mark reflection is around 400 to 500 words. The form has to be tight.
What is specificity in the reflection?Show answer
The reflection rewards specificity. A reflection that talks about "voice" or "imagery" or "structure" in general terms is not yet doing the work. A reflection that names a specific move at the level of sentence or paragraph is.
What is naming the mentor text?Show answer
If the reflection engages a mentor text, it should name the text, characterise the move, and argue the transfer.
What is evaluating the piece?Show answer
The evaluation move is the part students most often skip. The rubric explicitly asks for evaluation. Critical self-evaluation is the difference between a reflection that scores well and one that scores moderately.
What is the reflection on a longer assessment?Show answer
In school-based assessments, the reflection is often longer (800 to 1500 words) and more comprehensive. The form expands but the principles do not change.
What is voice in the reflection?Show answer
The reflection has its own voice. It is critical, evaluative, and self-aware without being arch.
What is common mistakes?Show answer
Restating the piece. The reflection retells what the piece does.
What is to demonstrate conscious craft?Show answer
The piece itself shows what the writer made. The reflection shows that the writer knows what they made and why. A piece without a reflection can score, but the reflection adds the evidence of intent.
What is to name the engagement with mentor texts?Show answer
The reflection is the place where mentor-text influence becomes explicit. A piece that absorbed a craft move from a prescribed text can articulate that absorption in the reflection.
What is to evaluate?Show answer
The reflection is a moment of critical self-assessment. The writer can name what the piece does well and what the piece does less well. Critical evaluation is part of the rubric.
What is restatement?Show answer
A reflection that summarises what the piece does ("In my piece, I wrote about the loss of a grandmother. The piece uses imagery to convey grief."). The marker has read the piece.
What is self-promotion?Show answer
A reflection that lists the piece's strengths without evaluation ("My piece successfully demonstrates voice, tone, and mood. The reader will feel moved."). The marker is suspicious of self-promotion.
What is content discussion?Show answer
A reflection that talks about the topic of the piece rather than the craft of the piece. The reflection should be about how, not about what.