Unit 4: Challenge and change in the post-war world, 1945-2010

VICModern HistorySyllabus dot point

How did the US civil rights movement challenge segregation and change American law and society between 1954 and 1968?

the US civil rights movement (1954 to 1968), including Brown v Board of Education (1954), the Montgomery bus boycott (1955 to 1956), the role of Martin Luther King Jr and the SCLC, the SNCC and direct action, the Civil Rights Act (1964), the Voting Rights Act (1965), and the rise of Black Power

A focused answer to the VCE Modern History Unit 4 dot point on the US civil rights movement. Brown v Board, the Montgomery bus boycott, Little Rock, the SCLC and SNCC, the Freedom Rides, the March on Washington, the Civil Rights Act and Voting Rights Act, the Watts riot, Black Power, the assassination of Martin Luther King Jr, and the verdicts of Taylor Branch and Manning Marable.

Generated by Claude OpusReviewed by Better Tuition Academy10 min answer

Have a quick question? Jump to the Q&A page

What this dot point is asking

VCAA expects you to explain how the postwar civil rights movement dismantled the legal architecture of Jim Crow segregation in the American South between Brown v Board of Education (1954) and the assassination of Martin Luther King Jr (1968). Strong responses pair the major federal landmarks (Brown, the Civil Rights Act, the Voting Rights Act) with the grassroots campaigns (Montgomery, Little Rock, Birmingham, Selma) and name at least two historians.

The answer

The Jim Crow context

After Reconstruction collapsed (1877), Southern states built a legal system of racial segregation. Plessy v Ferguson (18 May 1896) endorsed "separate but equal" public facilities. Black voters were disenfranchised through literacy tests, poll taxes, white primaries, and violence. Around 4,400 lynchings of Black Americans were recorded between 1877 and 1950.

WWII began to shift the politics. Around 1.2 million Black Americans served in the segregated armed forces. The Double V campaign (1942) demanded victory abroad and victory at home. President Truman desegregated the federal civil service (Executive Order 9980) and the armed forces (Executive Order 9981, both 26 July 1948).

Brown v Board of Education (17 May 1954)

The NAACP Legal Defense Fund, under Thurgood Marshall, brought a coordinated challenge to school segregation. Five consolidated cases were argued before the Supreme Court. The unanimous opinion of Chief Justice Earl Warren in Brown v Board of Education of Topeka (17 May 1954) declared that "separate educational facilities are inherently unequal" and overturned Plessy in the field of public education.

Brown II (31 May 1955) ordered desegregation "with all deliberate speed," a deliberately vague phrase that allowed Southern resistance. The Southern Manifesto (12 March 1956), signed by 101 of 128 Southern members of Congress, pledged "massive resistance." By 1964, fewer than 2 per cent of Southern Black children attended desegregated schools.

The Montgomery bus boycott (1 December 1955 to 20 December 1956)

Rosa Parks's arrest on 1 December 1955 was not spontaneous: Parks was a trained NAACP secretary; the Women's Political Council had drafted a boycott plan months earlier. The Montgomery Improvement Association (MIA), led by 26-year-old Baptist minister Martin Luther King Jr, called a boycott that continued for 381 days.

Around 40,000 Black riders walked or used a Black-organised car-pool system. The MIA filed Browder v Gayle in federal court; the Supreme Court affirmed the lower court ruling on 13 November 1956 that bus segregation was unconstitutional. The boycott ended on 20 December 1956.

The Southern Christian Leadership Conference (SCLC) was founded on 10 January 1957 under King's leadership to coordinate church-based protest across the South.

Little Rock and the federal-state confrontation (September 1957)

Arkansas Governor Orval Faubus deployed the Arkansas National Guard on 4 September 1957 to prevent nine Black students from entering Little Rock Central High School. President Eisenhower federalised the National Guard and deployed the 101st Airborne Division on 24 September 1957. The Little Rock Nine attended classes under federal protection.

Faubus closed all Little Rock high schools for the 1958 to 1959 school year ("Lost Year") rather than desegregate. The Supreme Court in Cooper v Aaron (12 September 1958) reaffirmed Brown and rejected state interposition.

Sit-ins and the founding of SNCC (1960)

Four Black students sat at the segregated Woolworth's lunch counter in Greensboro, North Carolina on 1 February 1960. The sit-in movement spread to around 100 cities within months. By the end of 1960 around 70,000 people had participated and around 3,000 had been arrested.

Ella Baker, executive director of the SCLC, convened a meeting at Shaw University, Raleigh, on 16 to 18 April 1960 that founded the Student Nonviolent Coordinating Committee (SNCC). SNCC's leaders included John Lewis, Diane Nash, and (later) Stokely Carmichael.

The Freedom Rides (May to September 1961)

The Congress of Racial Equality (CORE) under James Farmer organised Freedom Rides to test the Supreme Court ruling in Boynton v Virginia (5 December 1960) that segregation in interstate bus terminals was unconstitutional. Black and white riders left Washington DC on 4 May 1961 in two buses.

A bus was firebombed at Anniston, Alabama on 14 May 1961. Riders were beaten by Klan members in Birmingham and Montgomery. SNCC riders continued the campaign. Around 436 people rode through the summer. The Interstate Commerce Commission ruled on 22 September 1961 that interstate terminals must be desegregated.

Birmingham and the March on Washington (1963)

Birmingham, Alabama under Public Safety Commissioner Eugene "Bull" Connor was a flagship target. The SCLC's Project C began on 3 April 1963. Children marched from 2 May 1963 (the Children's Crusade); Connor responded with fire hoses and police dogs. The televised images shocked national opinion. King's "Letter from Birmingham Jail" (16 April 1963) defended civil disobedience.

President John F. Kennedy delivered a civil rights address on 11 June 1963 and submitted a comprehensive civil rights bill on 19 June. NAACP Mississippi field secretary Medgar Evers was assassinated outside his Jackson home on 12 June 1963.

The March on Washington for Jobs and Freedom (28 August 1963) drew around 250,000 participants to the Lincoln Memorial. King's "I Have a Dream" speech became the defining oratorical moment of the movement. The 16th Street Baptist Church bombing in Birmingham (15 September 1963) killed four Black girls. Kennedy was assassinated on 22 November 1963; Lyndon Johnson pushed the civil rights bill through Congress.

The Civil Rights Act (2 July 1964) and Mississippi Freedom Summer

The Civil Rights Act, signed by Johnson on 2 July 1964, banned discrimination in public accommodations (Title II), in publicly funded programs (Title VI), and in employment (Title VII, enforced by the Equal Employment Opportunity Commission).

Mississippi Freedom Summer (June to August 1964) brought around 700 mostly white Northern volunteers to register Black voters and run "freedom schools." Three workers (James Chaney, Andrew Goodman, Michael Schwerner) were murdered by Klansmen with local police complicity at Philadelphia, Mississippi on 21 June 1964; their bodies were found on 4 August. The Mississippi Freedom Democratic Party challenged the all-white Mississippi delegation at the Democratic National Convention in Atlantic City (August 1964); Fannie Lou Hamer's televised testimony was a landmark.

Selma and the Voting Rights Act (1965)

Around two per cent of Selma, Alabama's eligible Black voters were registered. SCLC and SNCC ran a voter-registration campaign from January 1965. Demonstrators attempted to march from Selma to Montgomery on 7 March 1965 ("Bloody Sunday"); state troopers attacked them at the Edmund Pettus Bridge. Television coverage produced a national outcry.

President Johnson addressed Congress on 15 March 1965 ("We Shall Overcome"). The Selma to Montgomery march under federal protection took place from 21 to 25 March 1965, finishing with around 25,000 marchers. Voting rights activist Viola Liuzzo was murdered on 25 March driving marchers home.

The Voting Rights Act, signed on 6 August 1965, authorised federal voter registration in counties with patterns of discrimination, suspended literacy tests, and required federal preclearance of changes to voting laws in covered jurisdictions. Black voter registration in Mississippi rose from around 6.7 per cent (1965) to 59.8 per cent (1967).

The northern movement, Watts and Black Power

The movement turned north from 1965. The Watts riot in Los Angeles (11 to 17 August 1965) killed 34 and exposed the depth of urban Black poverty. The SCLC's Chicago Freedom Movement (1966) targeted housing segregation; King was injured by a rock in Marquette Park on 5 August 1966. The Fair Housing Act would not come until April 1968.

SNCC chairman Stokely Carmichael called for "Black Power" during the Meredith March in Mississippi (16 June 1966). The Black Panther Party for Self-Defense was founded in Oakland by Huey Newton and Bobby Seale on 15 October 1966. The Panthers' free breakfast programs, armed patrols of police, and ten-point program reframed Black politics around community control and self-defence.

Malcolm X (Nation of Islam minister, then independent after March 1964) had argued through the early 1960s for self-defence and Black nationalism. He was assassinated on 21 February 1965 at the Audubon Ballroom in New York.

Memphis, Poor People's Campaign, and King's assassination (1968)

King's Riverside Church speech (4 April 1967) opposed the Vietnam War, breaking with Johnson. The Poor People's Campaign (announced December 1967) aimed at economic justice across racial lines.

King travelled to Memphis to support the sanitation workers' strike (begun 12 February 1968). He delivered the "Mountaintop" speech on 3 April 1968. He was assassinated on the balcony of the Lorraine Motel on 4 April 1968 by James Earl Ray. Riots in around 100 American cities followed; 43 people were killed.

The Fair Housing Act (Civil Rights Act of 1968) was passed on 11 April 1968 in response. The Poor People's Campaign continued under Ralph Abernathy; Resurrection City on the National Mall was dismantled on 24 June 1968.

Historiography

Taylor Branch (Parting the Waters, 1988; Pillar of Fire, 1998; At Canaan's Edge, 2006) is the standard narrative history of "America in the King Years."

Manning Marable (Malcolm X: A Life of Reinvention, 2011) restores Malcolm X to centrality and complicates earlier hagiographies.

Charles Payne (I've Got the Light of Freedom, 1995) focuses on the grassroots organising tradition (Ella Baker, the Mississippi delta) often hidden behind King.

Jeanne Theoharis (The Rebellious Life of Mrs. Rosa Parks, 2013) recovers Parks as a lifelong militant, not the apolitical seamstress of myth.

Peniel Joseph (Waiting 'Til the Midnight Hour, 2006) is the standard history of Black Power as a movement, not just a slogan.

Common exam traps

Treating Brown as the start of integration. Brown was a legal landmark, but enforcement was minimal until federal intervention. By 1964, fewer than 2 per cent of Southern Black children attended desegregated schools.

Reducing King to "I Have a Dream." King's later positions (against Vietnam, on economic justice) made him a more divisive figure by 1968 than the 1963 march suggests.

**Calling Black Power "violent." ** Black Power was a programmatic call for community control, Black economic power and self-defence, with internal debates on tactics. The Black Panthers' armed patrols of police were legal under California open-carry law until 1967.

Forgetting women's leadership. The movement was disproportionately led by women on the ground (Ella Baker, Diane Nash, Fannie Lou Hamer, Septima Clark, Daisy Bates). Public spokespersons were mostly male, but organising was not.

In one sentence

Between 1954 and 1968 the US civil rights movement dismantled legal segregation in the South through Supreme Court decisions (Brown v Board, 17 May 1954) and mass nonviolent direct action (Montgomery 1955 to 1956, Birmingham 1963, Selma 1965), producing the Civil Rights Act of 1964 and the Voting Rights Act of 1965, but failed to break northern de facto segregation and economic inequality, and fragmented after 1965 into the rise of Black Power and the assassination of Martin Luther King Jr on 4 April 1968.

Past exam questions, worked

Real questions from past VCAA papers on this dot point, with our answer explainer.

Practice VCAA10 marksEvaluate the achievements and limitations of the US civil rights movement between 1954 and 1968.
Show worked answer →

A 10-mark "evaluate" needs a thesis, achievements, limitations, and a named historian.

Thesis. The movement dismantled legal segregation and secured the vote in the South, but failed to break the economic inequality of urban Black America and was fragmenting by 1968.

Legal achievements. Brown v Board (17 May 1954) overturned Plessy and declared school segregation unconstitutional. The Civil Rights Act (2 July 1964) banned discrimination in accommodations and employment. The Voting Rights Act (6 August 1965) authorised federal supervision of elections and banned literacy tests.

Direct action. The Montgomery bus boycott (1955 to 1956) made Martin Luther King Jr a national figure. The Little Rock Nine (September 1957) forced Eisenhower to send the 101st Airborne. Freedom Rides (May 1961) desegregated bus terminals. The Birmingham campaign (1963) and the March on Washington (28 August 1963, 250,000 attendees) produced the Civil Rights Act.

Limitations. Northern de facto segregation persisted. The Watts riot (August 1965, 34 dead) showed urban poverty was untouched. The Chicago Campaign (1966) and Poor People's Campaign (1968) made limited gains.

Fragmentation. SNCC moved to Black Power under Stokely Carmichael (June 1966). The Black Panthers (October 1966) emphasised armed self-defence. King was assassinated on 4 April 1968; riots followed in 100 cities.

Historiography. Taylor Branch (America in the King Years trilogy, 1988 to 2006) is the standard narrative. Manning Marable (Malcolm X, 2011) restores Malcolm X to centrality.

Conclusion. Legal segregation fell; economic and northern de facto segregation did not.

Practice VCAA4 marksExplain the significance of the Montgomery bus boycott (1955 to 1956).
Show worked answer →

A 4-mark "explain the significance" needs the event and two consequences.

The event. On 1 December 1955, Rosa Parks (a 42-year-old NAACP secretary) was arrested in Montgomery, Alabama for refusing to give up her seat to a white passenger on a city bus. The Women's Political Council and the Montgomery Improvement Association (under the new minister Martin Luther King Jr) called a one-day boycott on 5 December; it continued for 381 days. The Supreme Court in Browder v Gayle (13 November 1956) ruled bus segregation unconstitutional; the boycott ended on 20 December 1956.

Significance. (1) It launched mass nonviolent direct action as the central tactic of the movement and made Martin Luther King Jr a national figure. The Southern Christian Leadership Conference (SCLC) was founded in January 1957 to coordinate church-based protest across the South. (2) It demonstrated that economic boycotts (Black riders were 75 per cent of bus traffic) and federal court action together could break local segregation laws, a model used through the 1960s.

Related dot points