← Option: Improving Performance
What ethical issues are related to improving performance?
Use of technology to enhance performance: equipment and apparel (footwear, swimsuits, bikes), recovery technology, monitoring technology (GPS, heart rate, biomarkers), video and biomechanical analysis, ethical considerations of access and fairness
A focused answer to the HSC PDHPE Improving Performance dot point on technology. Equipment and apparel, recovery technology, GPS and biomarker monitoring, video and biomechanical analysis, and the access/fairness debate.
Have a quick question? Jump to the Q&A page
Technology has reshaped elite sport more than any other single factor in the last two decades. Equipment, apparel, monitoring, recovery, and analytical tools have all advanced substantially. The HSC syllabus expects you to know the main categories and to think through the ethical implications, particularly around access and fairness.
Equipment and apparel
Footwear
The most-discussed recent example. Carbon-plated marathon shoes (introduced by Nike with the Vaporfly in 2017 and now produced by every major running brand) have driven measurable performance improvements at all levels. The mechanism is a carbon plate that stores and releases energy in a way that improves running economy by 3-5%.
World records in distance running have fallen rapidly since 2017, with the carbon-plated shoes contributing significantly. World Athletics has imposed restrictions (sole thickness limits, plate count limits) but allows current designs in competition.
Other footwear advances include sport-specific cleats (football boots, golf shoes), spike configurations (sprinting, throwing), and grip technologies (basketball, court sports).
Swimsuits
The 2008-2009 polyurethane and neoprene swimsuit era produced dozens of world records in a 24-month window. FINA banned these suits in 2010, returning to textile-only swimwear. The episode is the canonical example of a technological advance forcing rule changes.
Bikes
Aerodynamic frames, time-trial bikes, disc wheels, deep-section wheels, aerodynamic positioning, and integrated cockpit designs have transformed cycling. The UCI imposes minimum bike weights and other restrictions to prevent technology from making the sport effectively unfair.
Australian Olympic and Commonwealth Games cycling success has substantial technology underpinning (the AIS Wattbike program, dedicated wind tunnel work, custom-fit equipment).
Other equipment
Tennis rackets, golf clubs, cricket bats, hockey sticks, surfboards - every piece of sporting equipment has been engineered over the last decades. The rules typically constrain dimensions and materials to keep the technology within the spirit of the sport.
Recovery technology
Cryotherapy chambers
Whole-body cold exposure at temperatures of -100 to -140°C for 2-3 minutes. Widely used in elite sport for recovery. Evidence of benefit beyond the placebo effect is mixed but the practice is widespread.
Compression equipment
Pneumatic compression boots (NormaTec and similar) apply progressive compression to legs. Athletes use them post-training and post-competition. Evidence supports reduced perceived soreness; objective performance benefits are smaller.
Altitude tents and chambers
Simulated altitude for "live high, train low" adaptation. Used by endurance athletes to boost red blood cell mass. Some sports have restrictions; most allow it.
Sleep technology
Mattresses, sleep tracking, light management, temperature management. Sleep is increasingly recognised as the single most important recovery factor, and athletes invest substantially in protecting it.
Recovery rooms and centres
Dedicated recovery facilities at AIS, state institutes of sport, and major club training centres. Combine multiple modalities (pools, cryotherapy, massage, nutrition support, sleep monitoring).
Monitoring technology
GPS units
Used in field sport (AFL, NRL, rugby, soccer, hockey). Track distance covered, speed, sprint distance, acceleration, deceleration. Data drives training load decisions and helps identify athletes at risk of injury.
Heart rate monitoring
From chest straps to wrist-based optical sensors. Tracks training intensity (relative to estimated max), recovery (HRV), and acute physiological stress.
Power meters
In cycling and rowing. Measure direct power output rather than relying on heart rate as a proxy. Allow precise training prescription.
Biomarker monitoring
Blood testing for ferritin, vitamin D, cortisol, testosterone, immune markers, and inflammation. Elite athletes have substantial blood work routinely; recreational athletes have less.
Sleep tracking
Wearable devices and bed-based tracking. Sleep duration, sleep stages, heart rate variability.
Wearables
Apple Watch, Garmin, Whoop, Oura ring. Aggregate multiple metrics. Recreational and elite athletes both use them, with the elite versions adding higher-quality sensors.
Video and biomechanical analysis
Video analysis
Standard practice in elite sport. Athletes review their performance, study opponents, and identify technical issues. Tools range from coaches' standalone footage to enterprise platforms (Hudl, Coach's Eye, Dartfish).
Motion capture
Force plates, 3D motion capture, marker-based systems used in dedicated biomechanics labs. Identifies technical issues at a level the eye cannot see. Used most in throwing, swimming, golf, batting/bowling cricket.
AI-based analysis
Computer vision now extracts athlete movement data from standard video footage. Tools that detected ball trajectory and player positioning automatically were elite-only a decade ago and are now available to community sport.
Ethical considerations
The technology conversation in sport keeps returning to a small set of issues.
Access and fairness
Technology that costs money creates inequality. Carbon-plated marathon shoes (10,000+. Custom-fit equipment, biomarker monitoring, and recovery technology compound the gap.
At the school level, this manifests as: high-fee private schools have professional sport science programs and equipment that public school athletes do not. The 2024-2026 discussion of public-school sports funding in Australia is partly about this gap.
At the international level, wealthy nations have technology programs that poorer nations cannot match.
Definition of the sport
Does technology change what the sport actually is? When carbon-plated shoes improved running economy by 3-5%, did marathon racing become a different sport? When polyurethane swimsuits broke records, were the records still comparable to pre-suit records?
Sport governing bodies make these calls case by case. World Athletics regulates shoes; FINA banned non-textile suits; UCI sets bike weight limits.
Coaching versus technology
Some argue that technology has replaced traditional coaching judgment with data analysis. The counterview is that good technology amplifies good coaching rather than replacing it.
Privacy and athlete welfare
Continuous monitoring of athletes raises privacy questions. Where is the data stored? Who has access? Can a club use medical and biomarker data to inform contract decisions or selection decisions in ways the athlete did not authorise?
Genetic testing and selection
Some elite programs screen for genetic markers associated with performance (ACE gene, ACTN3 gene). The science is preliminary but the ethical issues are significant - selecting young athletes based on genetics, predicting career trajectories from DNA, potentially excluding athletes who do not have "ideal" profiles.
Anti-doping crossover
Recovery technology (cryotherapy, altitude tents) sits in a grey zone between training and doping. The current line drawn by WADA permits most of it but reviews are ongoing.
How this connects to broader themes
This dot point ties to:
- Commercialisation (technology costs money and creates competitive advantage).
- Equity in sport (the access question).
- Drugs in sport (technology and PEDs both raise the "what is fair" question).
Strong HSC extended responses on technology in sport address what the technology does, what it costs, who has access, and what role governing bodies should play in regulating it.