How do we calculate probabilities involving the binomial distribution, including ranges and complements?
Compute exact probabilities for the binomial distribution including P(X=k), P(Xβ€k), P(Xβ₯k), and use complementary counting
A focused answer to the HSC Maths Extension 1 dot point on computing binomial probabilities. Exact pmf values, cumulative sums, complements (at least, at most), and standard problem patterns, with worked examples.
β¦ Generated by Claude Opus 4.8Β·11 min answerΒ·
Reviewed by: AI editorial process; not yet individually human-reviewed
NESA wants you to compute binomial probabilities of every type: exact P(X=k), ranges P(Xβ€k) or P(Xβ₯k), and at-least/at-most using complementary counting.
The answer
Exact probability
For XβΌB(n,p),
P(X=k)=(knβ)pk(1βp)nβk,k=0,1,β¦,n.
Cumulative probability (sum of pmf values)
P(Xβ€k)=i=0βkβ(inβ)pi(1βp)nβi.
For HSC problems with small n, sum the pmf values up to k.
For small k (like k=1 or k=2), this is much faster than summing k to n.
Standard problem patterns
Exact number of successes: P(X=k) directly from the pmf.
At least one success: P(Xβ₯1)=1βP(X=0)=1β(1βp)n.
No successes: P(X=0)=(1βp)n.
All successes: P(X=n)=pn.
Between two values: P(jβ€Xβ€k)=βi=jkβP(X=i).
Choosing the easier sum
If asked P(Xβ₯k) and nβk+1 is small, sum directly. If nβk+1 is large, use 1βP(Xβ€kβ1) (complementary).
For "at most k", consider whether k or nβk is smaller. If k is smaller, sum directly.
Complementary counting, stage by stage
The single most useful move in these questions is to count the complement when it is shorter. Take a five-question multiple-choice test with four options each, guessed at random, so XβΌB(5,0.25), and suppose the question asks for P(Xβ₯2), the probability of getting at least two right. The three panels show why the complement wins.
Stage 1, picture the whole distribution. The bars are the six probabilities P(X=0) through P(X=5) from the pmf. Getting "at least 2" right means the bars from k=2 rightward, which is four terms to add. That is doable but slow.
Stage 2, identify the shorter complement. The complement of "at least 2" is "fewer than 2", that is X=0 or X=1, the two leftmost bars (shown in accent). Only two terms: P(X=0)=(0.75)5β0.2373 and P(X=1)=(15β)(0.25)(0.75)4β0.3955.
Stage 3, subtract from one. The answer is everything that is not the complement: P(Xβ₯2)=1βP(X=0)βP(X=1)β1β0.2373β0.3955=0.3672. The accent bars now mark the region you actually wanted, found with two terms instead of four.
Why the binomial coefficient appears
The factor (knβ) in the probability formula counts the number of distinct orderings in which exactly k successes can fall among n trials. Each specific ordering has probability pk(1βp)nβk, and there are (knβ) of them, so the total probability of exactly k successes multiplies the two. This is also why binomial probabilities and the binomial theorem share the same coefficients: expanding (p+q)n produces exactly the terms (knβ)pkqnβk, and summing them over all k gives (p+q)n=1, confirming the whole distribution has total probability one.
How exam questions ask about binomial probabilities
Half the difficulty in these questions is converting English into the right probability statement, then choosing the shorter calculation. The wordings, and the inequality each one means, are:
"exactly k": P(X=k) straight from the pmf.
"at least k": P(Xβ₯k). For small k use the complement 1βP(Xβ€kβ1).
"at most k": P(Xβ€k), a direct sum from 0 to k.
"more than k": P(Xβ₯k+1), one step further than "at least k".
"fewer than k" / "less than k": P(Xβ€kβ1), stopping one short of k.
"between j and k (inclusive)": P(jβ€Xβ€k)=βi=jkβP(X=i).
"at least one": the most common complement of all, P(Xβ₯1)=1β(1βp)n.
Misreading "more than" as "at least" shifts the boundary by one and is a frequent source of lost marks. Once the inequality is fixed, decide whether a direct sum or a complement is the shorter calculation, and state which you are using.
Exam-style practice questions
Practice questions written in the style of NESA exam questions on this dot point, with worked answer explainers. The year tag is the paper they imitate, not the source.
2022 HSC Q274 marksA test has 5 multiple-choice questions, each with 4 options. A student guesses randomly. Find the probability they get at least 2 correct.
Markers reward using complementary counting, computing P(X=0) and P(X=1), and the subtraction.
2020 HSC Q243 marksA factory produces items, 5% of which are defective. A sample of 20 items is checked. Find the probability that exactly 1 item is defective.
Show worked answer β
XβΌB(20,0.05). P(X=1)=(120β)(0.05)1(0.95)19.
=20β 0.05β 0.9519=1β 0.9519β0.3774.
Markers reward setting up the binomial, the formula, and a numerical answer to 3 or 4 decimal places.